Don’t Leave the First Meeting to Chance


Lessons from my conversation with Lee Salz on the Authentic Sales Manager Podcast


Most of us became sales managers because we performed pretty well in sales.

Someone figured if we could close deals, we could teach others to do the same. What often gets missed is that leading people is a different job. I thought mistakenly that people knew what I knew and they would “figure it out”. I learned that did not produce consistent results.

On a recent episode of the Authentic Sales Manager Podcast, I sat down with Lee Salz, sales differentiation strategist and author of several sales relate d books including his latest, The First Meeting Differentiator. Our conversation centered on genuine care, clear expectations, and the discipline of defining how to sell.

If you lead a sales team or own a business that depends on sales, this one is worth your time.

Authenticity Starts with Genuine Care
When I asked Lee what an authentic sales manager means to him, he didn’t reach for a fancy definition. He pointed to something simple and rare: genuinely caring about the success of your people.

You can’t fake it. When you’re a salesperson, the focus is largely on your own number. When you become a sales manager, the job shifts. It’s about cultivating relationships that bring out the best in others. Their success becomes your success.

That sounds obvious. It isn’t. Plenty of people get the title and still sell for themselves first.

The Problem of the Selling Manager
Lee called out one of the hardest roles in sales: the selling manager. That’s the person who still carries a personal territory while also managing a team.

Every morning brings a conflict: Do I sell, or do I develop my people? If compensation favors personal production, the team suffers. If it favors team results, the territory dries up.

I’ve lived that dual role. For a little while, it looks like the efficient answer. It rarely plays out the way owners hope. Lee has a name for the fantasy: “disciple selling.” Elevate your top seller, put people underneath them, and somehow get five times the sales. That sounds great in a meeting. It doesn’t hold up in real life.

So what’s the answer for a smaller company?

Business owners need to sit down with that selling manager, look at the experience level of the team, and define realistic time allocation. Compensation has to line up with those expectations. Without that alignment, the role is set up to fail.

There’s an important nuance here. If the team is green, meaning new to the company or new to selling, Lee would discourage the selling-manager model. Those people need a leader in the field with them, teaching the ropes. The “selling” that manager should be doing is lockstep with the team, not off chasing a separate territory while the rookies starve for coaching.

With a more tenured team, the dual role can work because the manager isn’t needed on every call and in every conversation.

That distinction matters. One model does not fit every team.

Entrepreneurial Sounds Good. It Usually Isn’t.
Lee draws a sharp line between two kinds of sales environments.

Call a team “entrepreneurial,” and many owners smile like they’ve been complimented. Lee isn’t complimenting them. He’s naming a problem.

Entrepreneurial, in his language, means you hired salespeople and never defined how to sell for your company. They’re expected to blaze the trail and somehow figure it out. Some may eventually succeed. Most underperform or leave.

What high-performing organizations build instead is an execution environment. Leadership defines how to sell for the company, documents it in a custom sales playbook, and hires people who can execute that approach. Top sales organizations do not let every salesperson invent their own process each morning.

Lee’s manufacturing analogy sticks with me. If you hired ten people to make your widget, would you let them do it any which way they want? Of course not. It’s costly, inefficient, and full of avoidable mistakes.

So why do we accept that chaos in sales?

We don’t have to.

The First Meeting Is the Deal Foundation
One of Lee’s strongest points is that the first meeting sets the foundation for the entire opportunity. If that meeting is weak, the deal is usually weak too.

Yet many organizations still leave it to chance. They hire salespeople and essentially say, “Ask good questions and tell them about our stuff.”

Lee’s challenge to executives is simple: If every salesperson called and said they just had a great first meeting, what would you know for certain happened?

In most companies, the honest answer is nothing, because the first meeting was never prescribed.

I’ve asked a version of that question myself. A salesperson came back to the office excited. “We had a great first meeting.” I asked the obvious follow-up: “What made it great?”

His answer: “They listened.”

Not that he listened. That they listened.

Lee laughed because he’d heard the old dating joke. Two people go out. The guy tells his friend it was the best date ever. He talked the entire time. The woman tells her friend it was the worst night ever. All he did was talk.

Same meeting. Completely different experience.

If every salesperson invents their own definition of a “great” first meeting, inconsistency is baked into the process. That costs deals.

Clean Process Beats Manipulative Tactics
Lee didn’t arrive at this thinking by accident. His first job out of college was running a chain of gyms. He was writing commercials, building marketing plans, negotiating ad deals, and developing sales programs. It was on-the-job “figure it out” training. He even wrote a post-Christmas commercial and appeared in a full Santa suit.

He also put an incentive in place: sign up on your first visit and get $100 off.

One day, he took an older gentleman on a tour and shared the offer. The man looked at him and said, “Son, if the deal isn’t good tomorrow, it isn’t good today.” Then he walked out.

Lee said he never felt so dirty. That moment nearly pushed him out of sales. Instead, it pushed him to a better path. He scrapped the program. And to this day, he won’t teach anything deceptive or manipulative, anything that makes you want to take a shower after you say it.

That is selling with dignity.

Lee also shared a practical tool he calls the epiphany-question strategy. Nobody likes being lectured. Not prospects, not kids, not anyone. So instead of climbing on a soapbox and telling people what they should do, identify the insight you want them to reach. Then ask questions that lead them there.

When they say it, they own it. And when they own it, the next step often sounds like, “Is that something you could help me with?”

Closing doesn’t have to be a forced event. Handle the process well, and working together becomes a natural progression.

What Sales Leaders Can Do with This
Define how to sell for your company and get it on paper.
Set clear expectations and aligned compensation for any selling manager.
With newer reps, coach in the field. Don’t pretend a separate territory won’t compete with development.
Treat the first meeting as a critical process, not an individual art form.
Move from checking for understanding to checking for execution through role plays, joint calls, and teach-backs.
Eliminate tactics that tarnish the brand, even if someone swears they “work.”
Leaving salespeople to figure everything out on their own is not empowerment. It’s hoping. Authentic sales leaders take responsibility for defining the path, then coach people to walk it well.

Define the process. Coach the execution. Care about the people. The results tend to follow.


Listen to the full episode with Lee Salz for more on sales differentiation, playbooks, and leading with intention.
https://youtu.be/av5nLWG3yMo?si=QnRGFm6bsHHmAzrx